Ask any person under the age of 25 (or their parents, for that matter), and they are likely to be familiar with such iconic animated characters as Woody and Buzz, Nemo, Lightning McQueen, Wall-E, and Dug the dog – just to name a handful. The collaboration between Disney and Pixar has produced thirteen feature films to date, including their most recent installment, Brave. Disney-Pixar films have garnered a reputation as the premier brand of children’s entertainment, due to their flawless blend of stunning imagery and heartwarming stories. These films have incredibly high expectations, which may have been why I found myself slightly disappointed with Brave.
Princess Merida (Kelly Macdonald) has a passion for archery, and her unruly orange mane is almost as wild as she is – or desires to be, if only her mother (Emma Thompson) would permit it. Tired of rules, restraints, and potential suitors, Merida lashes out at the queen. She runs out into the Scottish woods, and happens upon a cottage, where a mysterious witch gives her a spell that she promises will help Merida “change her fate.” The spell turns out to be more terrible than Merida could have ever imagined, and she must quickly figure out how to undo it – before her family is torn apart forever.
While Brave holds up well as a film in general, it fell short of what I have come to expect from most Disney-Pixar films. (In fact, when the man sitting next to me in the theater asked his very young son if he liked the film, the son responded, “Yes. But Madagascar 3 was better.” ) The film is full of touching moments, funny beats, and extensive character development; but it lacks that grand, sweeping adventure that triggers this development. Merida undergoes a personal transformation, but takes no physical journey: most of the film takes place in her castle or the environment surrounding it. There is no “bad guy” – just an antagonistic situation. While that is all very well and good, I craved a little more classical adventure intertwined with the personal exploration.
Brave holds many thematic parallels to Pixar’s 2003 film, Finding Nemo. In fact, Brave is to mother-daughter relationships as Nemo is to their father-son counterparts. Yet Nemo did it much better (and, let’s face it, first).
About thirty minutes into Brave, the film takes a complete twist. For attentive viewers, it can be spotted ahead of time (there are several little clues, but I won’t spoil them here). We quickly realize that the plot is branching off into something new, and the themes morph accordingly. Merida is no longer fighting off potential suitors, but has a different, much grizzlier problem to solve. The film’s tagline is “Change your fate,” but I felt that this theme only came into play at the beginning, and dissipated from there. In fact, the only action Merida consciously took to change her fate ended up being the one that put her family in great danger.
I also had a hard time figuring out just what made Merida so “brave” in the first place. At the start of the film, she is tough and strong-willed, but filled with teenage angst and rebellion against her mother. She gradually learns to compromise and relate to her parents, but this makes her more open-minded than brave. Merida has the courage to stand up for herself and her beliefs, but isn’t this true of most Disney characters?
Let me be clear: Brave is good as a film in general. But as a Pixar film, it underwhelms. Better luck next time, Lasseter.